Showing posts with label BBC3. Show all posts
Showing posts with label BBC3. Show all posts

Saturday, 10 May 2014

TV: In The Flesh - Series 2


I watched the start of the second series of In The Flesh this week, and surprised myself by really enjoying it.


I’m not a fan of horror.  I feel guilty about dismissing a whole genre, because I like to think of myself as culturally open-minded,  but it doesn’t entertain me and I don’t really know why. 


I don’t like not getting it; it frustrates me that an entire genre can escape me.  A lot of my friends do like their horror (to the extent where some of them are involved in making horror films) so over the years I’ve seen some high-end examples that should have given me an 'in': a few Saw films, The Ring, Shaun Of The Dead, Dawn Of The Dead, Zombieland, Hostel - loads of the stuff really, and most of them in the end pretty much drew a blank, the occasional exception proving the rule.  If anyone wants to try me with more recommendations, recommend away!

It never works its gory charms and for me watching a horror film is a bit like staring at a blood-spattered magic eye poster for a few hours and then walking away baffled.  The only horror films I really enjoyed were Peter Jackson’s early attempts at film-making, Brain Dead and Bad Taste - they are extremely funny, good-natured and more fun than anything else he went on to make.  But that means that I enjoyed them as slapstick comedies rather than horror, so doesn’t really count.


The fact that I liked In The Flesh so much probably doesn’t count either then, because I enjoyed it as character-based drama that satirasies society.  Damn.  In The Flesh, nominally ‘about’ zombies but really uses them in an allegorical way to make a drama about society’s religious, racial and medical outsiders.  It’s set in a Northern community post-apocalypse and focuses mainly on 20ish Kieren, who suffers from Partially Deceased Syndrome (PDS).  He is an outsider who is making efforts at integration.  He takes medication to keep him ‘normal’ and wears contact lenses to hide his tell-tale glaring eyes.  He works in the local pub, but wants to go abroad and see Paris and gives every impression of being a normal 20 year old who just happens to be dead.  He represents the acceptable face of the undead – he wears make up to hide his dead flesh to make the point literal, in case the audience hadn’t picked up on that yet.  The idea of being a zombie is normalised into modern society in the same way that being a werewolf or ghost was in Being Human (albeit for more dramatic and less sitcom purposes).

He is not like the undead we see at the start of the episode, who perpetrate a terrorist attack on a tram by snorting some stuff that made them go batshit crazy and then killing everyone.  Not only do the trams in Nottingham look better than the Salford ones, you can bet NCT wouldn’t let that kind of thing happen on their turf.  These are the undead who give the undead a bad name, members of the Undead Liberation Army.  They have a cult-commune base, and Kieren’s old friend Amy is one of them.

The prejudice shown against the undead is all of the small town variety that UKIP trades on – women gossiping in corners, men sneering and making abusive comments in the pub.  In the midst of all this, a party called Victus has a new MP in town, trading on peoples’ fears of the other for political power (as if that could ever happen).  She is a black woman, in a rather unsubtle effort to show that being in a minority group herself does not mean she is not open to feelings of prejudice. 

It all kicks off in the pub at the end of the episode (it is made by BBC Salford after all), and it looks as if Kieren is going to stop trying to assimilate and join the revolutionaries, who are open about their difference to everyone if a little dogmatic with it…  It should be interesting to see what happens – I’m guessing that Kieren is going to enjoy the freedom in not having to pretend to be the same as everyone else for some time, but at some point is going to renounce their way of existing when they try to involve him in something naughty (possibly against his sister if the programme-makers are being unimaginative).  The UKIP, sorry, Victus MP has some agenda of her own which also drew me in – she’s already murdered a rabid undead, and persists in calling them ‘its’ instead of ‘hes’ or ‘shes’.  Bitch.  This was the start of a second series – I didn’t see (or, in fact, know the existence of) the first series and didn’t feel I was missing anything here, so I don’t know how much of this was a continuation or a new start.  It’s an interesting mashup of lots of different things, from thrillers to Coronation Street (the ladies bitching over a pint could have been cut and pasted from a soap), and although horror tropes are the most obvious ones on show, they’re actually the least integral to the storytelling.  Which is perhaps why I ended up enjoying it so much.

Saturday, 8 March 2014

TV: BBC 3 To Be Axed

I come to bury BBC3 with faint praise.



BBC3 is closing – or at least being consigned to an internet-only fate.  It’s always sad to hear news of cultural death, even when culture in this case often means repeats of (the long off-the-boil) Family Guy.  The last thing the BBC tried to cut that gathered this much press attention was when the 6 Music radio station was threatened with closure, but was granted a reprieve when there was a massive online campaign – we’ll get onto why I don’t think history will repeat itself later.



So - the BBC is trying to save money, and there’s nothing particularly new there – the BBC is always trying to save money.  Controversy always comes when big cuts are made.  Instead of each channel being told to make cuts, a whole channel is being scrapped.  It’s the BBC’s channel for youth, attracting under-30s in away that its other channels don’t.  Its death will be a massive blow to new comedy…

…according to the biased Russell Kane (where will he find the money to feed his hair now?)  The problem with this argument is that BBC3 isn’t producing good comedy often enough.  It is telling that every time the story has been reported on the news, Gavin and Stacey and Little Britain (programmes that ended 4 and 7 years ago respectively) are mentioned as BBC3s highlight programmes.  When someone is threatening to close your station you need to be able to make a strong case against by having really, really good current content.  And BBC3 will have trouble with this, because its strongest content now is repeats, either of its own programmes or of BBC1 big hitters like Eastenders or Doctor Who.  To an extent, you can see why the argument to make it an online only service makes sense because its schedules sometimes look like the homepage of the BBC iPlayer.  

It is more than possible that BBC3 is the fall guy here.  Whatever you say about the quality of BBC3’s programmes, BBC1’s schedules aren’t full to the brim with amazing originality either.  The thing is BBC1 isn’t good enough often enough to justify its existence sometimes.  On Friday night we watched the creaking Room 101 having its cobwebs blasted off yet again, followed by a very lacklustre Jonathan Creek; these programmes started last century and are frankly well past it.  BBC3 is getting all the attention, but it’s a scapegoat to distract attention from BBC1’s lack of originality and substance.  BBC1 could take more of a high ground were it not for the fact that a lot of its own programmes are quite shocking.  For all the criticism of BBC3’s ‘lowest common denominator’ comedy, it’s BBC1 that gives us Mrs Brown’s Boys, a show that goes about as low as common denominators go.

This is not to argue that BBC3 has lots of great programming, because it doesn’t.  It’s just to point out that its quality is not inconsistent with some of the BBC’s overall TV output.  There was talk of BBC4 and BBC2 being combined to save money, and instead they’ve chosen to make BBC3 an online only service.  In my opinion they should have combined BBC3 with BBC1.  BBC3 makes just enough quantity of quality programming that it could easily displace some of BBC1’s screensaver dross and make the main channel more attractive to young people.  The programmes it repeats all the time could be made permanently available on the iPlayer (if not already there) and comedy like Russell Howard’s Good News and Bad Education could liven up BBC1’s stagnant comedy scheduling a bit (and Russell Howard is putting the main channel’s comedy output to shame should be pretty shaming in itself...)  It would be nice to have an inclusive main channel again anyway.  What’s wrong with having the main channel do some under-30s programming, rather than putting it out in a ghetto with no crossover appeal?

BBC3 as a concept is insulting to its own audience by implying that they don’t merit being catered for on a mainstream channel, and instead need an underfunded ghetto filled with repeats.  And because the BBC in general treats BBC3’s audience with a degree of contempt, it hasn’t got a loyal audience.  This is where the comparisons with the 6 Music almost-closure fails.  For a start, 6 Music was a radio station and BBC3 is a TV channel – the stakes are much higher in TV because more time and money is involved in making an evening’s worth of programmes than in paying a DJ to play records all evening.  But that aside, they are two fundamentally different media, absorbed in different ways.  Radio stations get loyal listeners much more easily because they find a DJ they like, trust them to choose the music, and if they don’t like a track it’ll change in 3 minutes or so.  

In the 21st Century, TV channels do not get loyal viewers partly because of the surfeit of choice - people channel-hop until they find something good on.  Only certain programmes still have people tuning in specifically for them live, mainly the soaps and ‘Event’ series like Sherlock.  It’s the programmes that have the loyal viewers, not the channel.  People can get passionate about a genre of music and be (for instance) a punk fan; but it’s rare for people to be a fan of a genre of television – there aren’t many drama, documentary or panel-show fans.  When it comes to television peoples’ tastes are more specific and discerning, even when they are tastefully discerning to watch is Snog, Marry, Avoid.

Anyway, 6 Music was in a better position to start a grass-roots campaign because of the relative diversity of its audience.  6 Music’s audience spans more than one demographic; it has different programmes catering for different tastes and ages throughout the week.  BBC 3 has all its eggs in the same under-30s basket.  A basket which (people more cynical than myself might argue) is made up of people more likely to shrug their shoulders and switch to E4 or Sky Living or Comedy Central (or even BBC1).  

It would be extremely satisfying if BBC3 came out with some blinding hit comedies to make the decision seem ridiculous, but it doesn’t seem very likely. If it could point to a list of 10 crucial programmes it has produced in the last 4 years it would be in with more of a chance, but frankly it can only just about manage to do that for its entire existence (and even to do that you have to include Two Pints Of Lager And A Packet Of Crisps).  In principle it’s a shame.  But in practice, I think we’ll live without it.